Monday, April 9, 2012

Anatomy of Urban Investments in Mumbai


India’s growth story has many facets; one of the integral parts of growth – and arguably the most important one – is urbanization. In fast-growing economies, cities are significant investment and employment generators, which in turn carry the growth momentum forward. The sustainability and livability of any city depends largely on the quality of its infrastructure and real estate stocks. Needless to say, cities also require large sums of money to create urban asset stocks, including buildings and infrastructure.

Over last decade, India’s population grew by 18% while its urban population grew at almost double that rate (at 32%). Currently, about 31.2% of India’s population lives in urban areas. The country’s share of urban population has increased by almost 3.5% over the last decade. What is even more astounding is the increase in the built-up real estate stock in its cities and towns.

Data from the 2001 census shows that about 110 million ‘Census Houses’ exist in the urban areas, which indicates an increase of 39 million over the last 10 years. In other words, real estate stock shows a compounding growth of 4.5 % per annum as against the growth rate of 2.8% in urban population. Obviously, such massive growth needs adequate support from infrastructure.

However, the state of affairs with infrastructure in Indian cities is not very encouraging. Most of the cities still have to deal with issues in terms of roads, public transportation, sanitation, storm water drainage, solid waste management systems, etc. on a regular basis. With the volume of real estate stock increasing inexorably in the cities, there is an acute problem with the basic needs like energy and water in the store for urban India.

The private sector contributes most of the development of real estate stock; however, the responsibility of infrastructure development lies squarely with public sector entities such as ULBs and other utility companies – most of which are Government agencies. The investment pattern in our cities shows a similar trend – the private sector invests in the development of real estate stocks, while the public sector invests largely into infrastructure development.

The quantum of investments in most infrastructure projects is huge, and the agencies responsible for its development are seriously under-financed. They depend either on domestic grants like JNNURM or on intercalation financing involving bilateral and multilateral agencies.

In some instances, funds are mobilized from private sources in the form of Public Private Partnership. The private sector generally tends to shy away from investments into city-level infrastructure projects, as most of these projects are considered non-remunerative. They prefer to focus on investing into the development of real estate stock.

Mumbai – A Case Study

Mumbai, India’s financial capital, attracts massive investments – largely in the real estate sector. The city being the nation’s epitome of high real estate prices and land scarcity, huge sum of money keep chasing land in the city – while infrastructure augmentation lags behind. Way behind.

The opening up of FDI in real estate in 2005 opened the floodgate for investors vying for a share in the juicy pie that Mumbai real estate represents:

Prime Land Deals in Mumbai City Since 2005

Since 2005, there have been many record-breaking land transactions in Greater Mumbai – mostly from NTC mill lands and by MMRDA at Bandra Kurla Complex (BKC). Some of the aggressive land purchasers were IndiaBulls, Lodha Developers, Piramal Sunteck, Wadhwa and Peninsula Land Limited, among others.

A whopping Rs. 276 billion have been invested in land in Mumbai since 2005 – and this does not even include the confidential transactions and investments made into Slum Rehabilitation projects (SRA) and other redevelopment projects. The sum of the unaccounted transactions could possibly be another Rs. 100 billion in the same time period.

Patterns of Investment in Land Over Time

In terms of investment sizes and the total quantum of investment, South Mumbai leads the pack, followed by the Western zone – primarily because of land auctions at BKC. The East zone attracted the least investments – most of them into defunct industries along LBS Marg. Interestingly, CIDCO at Navi Mumbai has also been able to mobilize massive funds through the auction of plots at different nodes. The level of infrastructure, social amenities and economic activities has pushed up the real estate prices of Navi Mumbai – and they are still rising.

From a city-level perspective, it is important to understand whether the large volumes of investments in land have actually delivered a proportionate development of real estate stocks in the city:

Prime Residential Unit Launches

The data indicates that about 2.5 lakh dwelling units have been launched in Mumbai over the last five years. Some of this stock has been constructed and delivered, while part of it is still under construction or at the approvals stage. If, for the sake of an argument, we consider the entire stock of dwelling units and the average investment for the land component per dwelling unit, it works out to over a million rupees.

In other words, the direct beneficiaries of these real estate investments are, at best, about 2.5 lakh households (considering one family occupying one dwelling unit) or less than 10% of the city’s population.

On the other hand, if we look at the investments made in the city’s infrastructure (which aims to cater to 100% of the population) the situation is very different:

Prime Infra Projects in Mumbai since 2005
Total investment (crores)

Monorail
 2,716

36 Skywalks
 735

MUTP Phase II
 5,300

MUIP
 2,648

Extended MUIP
 1,550

Mumbai Metro – Versova-Andheri-Ghatkopar Corridor
 2,356

Total
 15,305

The data indicates that the quantum of investments in mega infrastructure projects amounts to only 60% of the investments made in prime land in the city, approximately in the same period. If we look at the present status of these infra projects, most of them are stuck in various bottlenecks and running abysmally behind schedule. One of the main reasons for this is inadequate funds arriving far too sporadically.

On a hypothetical note – had the authorities had the kind of money that the private sector invested in prime land, the city of Mumbai would have been transformed much faster.

Going forward, the funds requirement for infrastructure projects will increase further. Many mega projects which are extremely critical in terms of enhancing mobility, clearing up traffic congestion and thereby improving the overall quality of life in the city have been planned:

To be added
Total investment (crores)

MTHL
 8,800

Worli Haji Ali Sea Link
 1,120

Mumbai Metro – Charkop-Bandra-Mankhurd
 8,250

Mumbai Metro – Colaba-Bandra Corridor
 9,400

Total
 27,570

The city of Mumbai needs additional investments of about Rs. 275 billion in the infrastructure sector over the next five years if these projects are to be completed on schedule. This is equal to the amount that the city has buried in its land. The paradox of the situation is that, despite sitting on such massive money resources, Mumbai is unable to generate to fund its most essential requirements.

Much of the investments in land, particularly in South Mumbai, have actually remained non-yielding. The complexities of the Development Control rules, the approval process and policy flip-flops have virtually kept the supply side down for several months. Investors have not been able to fully monetize their investments, and the end users have faced spiraling price rises despite economic slowdowns.

This would be an apt time for the authorities and policy makers to focus on breaking this deadlock. The need of the hour is to view real estate and infrastructure development in Mumbai cohesively, not as isolated phenomena. There are enough ingredients for solutions available within the system.

IT corridors ideal for property investment in Hyderabad


Property market in Hyderabad is concentrated along IT corridors like Hi-Tech City, Kondapur and Gachibowli. All categories of housing have been active in the city – multi-storey apartments, houses and villas. According to market sources, despite Telangana issue, demand has remained constant for both domestic and international property buyers. In some areas like Gachibowli and Hi-Tech City, demand for villas matches multi-storey apartments demand.

Infrastructure development like the International Airport, completion of the Outer Ring Road (ORR), about 30 radial roads, MMTS, metro, procurement of water from Krishna and Godavari rivers, etc are all attracting global MNCs and investors to start their operations in Hyderabad.

According to G Yoganand, CMD, Manjeera Group, “The city has witnessed second highest occupancy of IT spaces in India during last one year. Hence, this is the best time for property buyers because Hyderabad may witness property boom in the mid-term. IT Corridor is the best place for investment. The mode depends on the budget. A plot in a good location is always the best but you will not get loan.”

IT corridor areas like Gachibowli, Kondapur, Madhapur, Nallagandla, Nanakram Guda, Kokapet, APPA junction, Hi-Tech City are ideal for investment.

According to MagicBricks.com, Hi-Tech City has seen an increase of 17% in values of multi-storey apartments in the Jan-Mar quarter this year compared to Oct-Dec quarter in 2011.

When talking about where the maximum demand is coming from, Yoganand added that Hyderabad has investors from across the country. “Even now, many people from Andhra region are buying and they are not worried about Telengana. Whether Telangana or no Telengana, Hyderabad is the best place in India to invest for better appreciation. Hyderabad has the best infrastructure, cosmopolitan culture, no language barrier, less pollution, better weather conditions, and better connectivity by road, rail and airways to all important cities of India. Prices are also reasonable,” he added.

Infrastructure is a key reason for the increase in demand in Hyderabad as well as for the rise in property values. A major infrastructure development has been the commencement of the Phase I of Metro covering Nagole and Gachibowli, market sources say. Rakesh Sudam of Earthwide Properties pointed out that infrastructure like the Phase I of Metro will affect localities like Nagole, Uppal and Gachibowli. “Values are already rising here and are expected to rise by 5 to 10% in the next 3 to 6 months,” Sudam said.

Buildings may get taller as Panel seeks higher FSI


The skyline of Indian cities could soar as the government considers permitting vertical growth with the aim of checking runaway realty prices and generating resources to upgrade urban infrastructure for future growth.

A Planning Commission steering committee, in its draft report, has recommended providing additional FSI (floor space index; the ratio between built-up area and plot size) as development rights, but said it should not come free of cost.

The panel said the charges for additional FSI and land-use conversions should be at least 50% of the circle rate in the area and should be determined professionally. It added that additional FSI should be permitted selectively.

The commission’s steering group on urbanization said the revenue from grant of additional FSI should be “suitably ringfenced for funding infrastructure projects to sustain higher FSI”.“The proposals, if accepted, would substantially increase availability of housing stock and moderate realty prices,” said an urban development ministry official.

Calling the present density regulations in Indian cities “archaic”, the report noted that Indian cities had the lowest FSI in the world. “This (densification) should be part of a balanced strategy for expanding the effective supply of prime land and, in the process, raising funds to finance urban infrastructure improvements,” the panel noted.

Sunday, April 8, 2012

HDFC may reduce home loan rates soon


India’s biggest mortgage lender HDFC says home loan seekers can expect a 0.5-0.75% reduction in interest rates ahead of the festival season if the Reserve Bank of India reduces rates later this month.

“If market rates come down, it normally takes us two-to-three months to pass it on because our liabilities get re-priced,” HDFC’s managing director Renu Sud Karnad said. She said she was hoping that the central bank would reduce rates at its annual monetary policy review on April 17.

The RBI has raised interest rates 13 times since March 2010, by a cumulative 375 basis points in its efforts to tame inflation.

Costlier loans have forced potential home buyers to postpone their purchase decisions and have, in turn, impacted the real estate market. Homes sales in Mumbai have dipped by over 40% in the last one year while other cities have seen a 20% drop.

Karnad, however, said high interest rates have not had much impact on home sales falling in the Rs 20-50 lakh bracket, whether in big cities or Tier II cities, because the need and demand for homes in this price range continues to remain high. She said HDFC’s home loan portfolio has increased in the last one year, but did not share the numbers.

“There is no concern or worry among young, middle-income Indians wanting to buy a house except in Mumbai, which is expensive,” Karnad said.

While most cities across the country have seen steady home sales in the last few months, Mumbai has been a concern for developers as well as lenders. Karnad, however, said even in Mumbai sales are happening in the suburbs, where price points are still affordable.

Home loan growth in smaller cities too has been phenomenal. Cities like Baroda, Lucknow, Chandigarh and Salem have seen 30-40% 0growth in home loans. “These markets might be small and this growth might be on a smaller base, but the fact is that there is demand. What they need is better supply of homes,” Karnad said. She said that the market expects a 10-15% cut in home prices, which seems to be high. Karnad also pointed out that builders are faced with rising cost of construction. Prices of cement, steel and labour have grown in the last two months, she added.

Commercial properties in Delhi witness stable values


Commercial properties in areas such as Paharganj, Jhandewalan, Motia Bagh and Daryaganj have witnessed stable values owing to numerous factors. Realtors believe that these are traditional areas and have old and dilapidated commercial buildings.

Secondly, since they are located in Central Business District (CBD) areas, roadblocks like traffic jams, uneven roads and poor connectivity are deterrents to growth here. That’s why these areas are seeing stable value trends with no major escalation or increase in the number of transactions, realtors said.

Praveen Sethi of City Properties said that capital and rental values in these areas are showing a stable trend. Another city-based realtor, Gaurav Bhatia from Properties & Properties said, “There are more queries than actual number of transactions. Availability of better commercial office space options in National Capital Region (NCR) such as Noida and Gurgaon is diverting buyer’s mindset.”

Balbir Singh, Chairman of Vardhaman Plaza reiterated that, “Once the problems like connectivity and traffic jams are addressed, the commercial values will take an upward trend.” However, there are some renovation projects also going on and old buildings are getting designed as per new standards to meet the demand but this will take some time.

To address these issues, there is a proposed plan of monorail in these areas within next 2-3 years. The plan is already approved and the basic work has also started, Singh said. This will speed up the travelling time to these areas and also resolve traffic issues.

Enhanced connectivity will definitely uplift these areas and improve the demand and number of transactions. Further renovated buildings with proper parking space, good infrastructure, security and other facilities will push the commercial property market, Sethi added.

The current capital values of commercial shop and office space at Pahar Ganj, Jhandewalan and Motia Khan is in the range of 9,000-30,000 per sq ft. With the proposed monorail plan combined with infrastructure facilities is likely to bring back buyers to CBD areas.

Delhi Master Plan 2021


The Master Plan of Delhi 2021 has been in force since 2007. Once this is reimplemented with the new land development policy, Delhi will also offer options to thousands of home buyers. The capital city has still 27,628.9 hectares of land to fulfil the dreams of thousand of home buyers.

The DDA (Delhi Development Authority) has earmarked land at Zone J, K1, K2, M, N, L, O, P1 and P2 for raising residential projects. According to the projections in the master plan, nearly 24 lakh residential units are required for an estimated 23 million people by 2021.

According to the master plan, Delhi will be slum-free in the next 10 years by providing rehabilitation packages (built-up houses with all civic facilities) to slum dwellers. For this DDA has identified 23 sites (slum areas) for rehabilitation. The master plan of Delhi includes chapters like regional and sub-regional frame, population and employment, Delhi urban area 2021, social and physical infrastructure, mixed land-use regulations, development code and plan review and monitoring.

The master plan 2021 has allocated 277 sq km for future urbanization by 2021. In the last fifty years, DDA has acquired 75,609.84 hectares and developed it for residential, recreational, commercial and institutional purposes.

Now, with better and holistic planning, DDA intends to set new records and provide more amenities to people. Delhi is spread over 1,483 sq km and divided into 17 planning zones: 1,159 hectare in Zone-A (Old City); 2,304 hectare in Zone-B (City Extension and Karol Bagh); 3,959 hectare in Planning Zone-C (Civil Lines); 6,855 hectares in Zone D (New Delhi); 8,797 hectares in Planning Zone-E (East Delhi); 11,958 hectares in Zone-F (South Delhi I); 11,865 hectares in Planning Zone-G (West Delhi I); 5,677 hectares in Zone-H (North-West Delhi I); 15,178 hectares in Zone-J (South Delhi II); 5,782 hectares in Zone K-I (West Delhi II) and 6,408 hectares in Zone K-II Dwarka; 22,840 hectares in Zone-L (West Delhi III); 5,073 hectares in Zone-M (North West Delhi II); 13,975 hectares in Zone-N (North West Delhi III); 80,70 hectares in Zone-O (River Yamuna-River Front); 9,866 hectares in Zone P-I (Narela) and 8,534 hectares in Zone P-II (North Delhi).

Ram Gopal Gupta, a policy maker and city planner, says: “In the last 40 years, DDA constructed only 3.5 lakh flats. However, these did not suffice even for 1% of Delhi’s population. Due to lack of housing facilities in Delhi, 10 lakh people are dependent on nearby sates and metro cities in the NCR belt. According to records, DDA was constructing 10,000 flats every year 15 years ago, while in the last 10 years it managed to build 54,000 flats. Today, DDA is not in a position to construct even 5,000 flats a year. The dramatic growth in Delhi’s population has led to congestions and shortages of civic amenities. One of the main causes for this spurt in population is the migration of people into the city from Bihar, UP, Punjab, J&K, West Bengal, Orissa, etc.”

Solution

Today, the NCR cities are best suited to take the burden of housing from the national capital. The NCR has a total area of 33,578 sq km and includes parts of three states, Haryana, Rajasthan, and Uttar Pradesh, with Delhi as a full state.

The NCR is also characterized by the presence of ecologically sensitive areas like the extension of the Aravali ridge, forests, wild life and bird sanctuaries; the river systems of Yamuna and Hindon, and is a dynamic rural urban admixture.

Sub-regions of NCR

The Haryana sub-region comprises nine districts: Faridabad, Gurgaon, Mewat, Rohtak, Sonipat, Rewari, Jhajjar, Panipat and Palwal, together constituting about 40% of the region.

The Uttar Pradesh sub-region comprises five districts: Meerut, Ghaziabad, Gautam Budh Nagar, Bulandshahr, and Baghpat, together constituting about 32% (10,853 sq km) of the region.

The Rajasthan sub-region comprises Alwar district and constitutes about 23% (7,829 sq km) of the region. The NCT (National Capital Territory) of Delhi constitutes about 5% (1,483 sq km) of the region.

Development

In recent times, there has been a tremendous growth of Delhi and the NCR in terms of infrastructural developments and with the advent of major realty players like DLF, Ansal API, Ansal Housing, Unitech, BPTP,Amrapali, Supertech, Gaursons, Assotech, Parsvnath, Ashiana, TDI, Anantraj Group, Omaxe, JP, Antriksh, etc, the areas have been much in news.

Areas like Gurgaon, Noida, Greater Noida, Manesar, Faridabad, East Delhi Extension, etc, have been the areas fulfilling the housing needs of millions of people who live in and around Delhi. With the pressure of increasing population, unavailability of land, and lowering of water table, etc, developers are migrating to new places in the NCR to raise residential and commercial projects.

Rehabilitation scheme for slumdwellers

A novel project proposed by DDA, the “in situ” rehabilitation scheme, moves away from the agency’s previous model of shifting slumdwellers to the city’s fringes as part of rehabilitation package. For this, DDA has indentified 23 sites (slum areas). Consultants have already been appointed for 13 sites.

The Kathputli colony near Shadipur Depot of North Delhi has been taken up in first phase. Tenders will also be floated for the other 22 identified sites. Raheja Developers has been awarded the first of its kind, in situ slum re-development project over 5.22 hectares at Kathputli colony by DDA.

The project envisages construction of 2,800 EWS units (with built-up area 30 sq metres per unit) with community facilities like a multi-purpose hall, Basti Vikas Kendra, a health centre, a Sishu Vatika, etc. Arabtec, the firm which built Burj Khalifa in Dubai, will construct these 2,800 EWS houses and also the commercial complex under the slum redevelopment public-private partnership project between Raheja Developers and DDA, in a time-bound contract of two years.

Demand for office space drops in metros


Office space demand slowed down in the first quarter of 2012, with around 4.1 million sq ft getting absorbed across the leading cities in the country.

In the previous quarter (Oct-Dec 2011), almost 6.5 million sq ft was absorbed, according to the India Office report released by CBRE on Thursday. NCR (National Capital Region), Mumbai, Chennai and Bangalore were the leading cities accounting for more than 70% of the entire space getting absorbed in the country.

Supply continued to overtake demand in the first quarter of 2012, almost 5.9 million sq ft of office space was added in leading cities. The new supply was largely concentrated in NCR, Bangalore, Mumbai and Chennai, comprising almost 90% of the entire quantum of the present quarter.

The report said Mumbai witnessed decline in rental values at Nariman Point and Lower Parel, mainly due to sluggish demand levels. Average rentals in Grade A buildings in Nariman Point dropped from Rs 300 a sqft a month in December last to Rs 290 in March.In Lower Parel, it reduced from Rs 155 to Rs 150 in the period. “It is anticipated that supply dynamics will continue to dictate rental movement in coming quarters, with values in the CBD being stable and those in suburbs slipping,” it said.

Nariman Point has limited transactions with only a marginal absorption of around 10,000 sq ft. “It did not witness the addition of any fresh supply in the present quarter and vacancy remained stable. In coming few quarters, vacancy in this micro-market is slated for rise from the current estimated 6-7%,” said the report.

A marginal decline was seen in rental values during the quarter. Around 2 lakh sq ft of Grade-A office space became available in the Extended Business District (EBD) of Lower Parel. Worli and Prabhadevi saw a marginal correction of 1-3% in rental values. “The decline was largely due to low levels of transactions…,” it said.

BKC continued to remain a preferred location for corporate occupiers looking for expansion. The CBRE report also observed limited leasing activity in the Secondary Business District (SBD) of Andheri, Vile Parle and Jogeshwari.